![]() ![]() ![]() And whether the dispute was regarding the external links or not, he was involved in editing the aricle and he should not review it. Chase wc 91 01:02, 8 January 2010 (UTC) Reply Piano non troppo is vehemently being aggressive regarding this article and it totally shows from the comments on his talk page that he is reviewing the article with the intention of failing it. Judging from my scanning of the page after reading the review, I would like to add that I think Piano's comment about this being a "PR piece to promote Lady Gaga" is extreme, untrue, and an exaggeration. Please let another editor who has little to no editing history at this page assess this so that bias is not an issue. I have not checked the history of the article, but Piano non troppo, if you indeed have been involved in a recent dispute, it would not be wise to continue with your review. ![]() Jezhotwells ( talk) 03:44, 7 January 2010 (UTC) Reply Hello, happened to stop by and notice the disagreement occurring here. Legolas ( talk 2 me) 03:33, 7 January 2010 (UTC) Reply I concor, it does not seem appropriate for you to review this article. Your above statements simply show that you are letting your biasness come in the way of your review. Piano non troppo ( talk) 11:30, 6 January 2010 (UTC) Reply This is so state in the politest way possible but I would request you to step down from editing the article as you were associated in an edit content disagreement and cannot be a reviewer for the article. The article misses half the point about what makes the song and video distinctive. In short, it's a PR piece to promote Lady Gaga, herself. Almost nothing about the people involved in running the equipment. The song has the following chord progression, Ab–Cm–Fm–Db–Ab–Cm–Fm–Db–Db." There's nothing about the musical instruments, the recording process, the audio editing process, the circumstances of shooting the video, the video equipment, the video editing. The song is set in common time, and Gaga's vocal range spans from the high-note of G3 to the lower base of E♭5. From a musician's point of view, the song is described in a only a couple sentences, "The song has a moderate electro-synth groove and it is composed in the key of C minor with a tempo of 116 beats per minute. The article is comprised of critical reviews, aesthetic interpretations, sales figures, an aimless, sterile list of dozens of remixes, and painfully detailed literal descriptions of individual song performances. It does not address the main aspects of the topic. Broad in coverage without going into unnecessary detail. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |